Every tree company has a version of this guy. He's good in the tree, he knows it, and somewhere along the way he decided that put him above the ground crew. He'll make a mess all day and never pick up a rake. Climber's ego is very real in this trade, and it has a specific shape.
A crew that ranks itself by who's in the air can't run without a boss standing over it. The ego is what keeps the crew from organizing itself, and a crew that can't organize itself is one more thing that only works while you're on site.
The shape it takes
Aerial workers put themselves above the groundies and start refusing ground work. That's the obvious version. Pull up on a job and you can see it: the climber done and leaning on the truck while three guys drag brush around him.
There's a quieter version, and it's worse because it looks like hustle. A crew leader I worked with had it. He'd get a pile of material on the ground, bury his guys in it, and head to the next job instead of helping them get caught up first. He wasn't standing around. He was gone. Same ego, expressed by leaving instead of refusing.
He wasn't standing around. He was gone. Same ego, expressed by leaving instead of refusing.
Both versions say the same thing to the crew: my time is worth more than yours, and the mess I make is your problem. The guys on the ground stop caring about the pace. The guy in the air stops caring about the ground.
It's an owner problem, not a climber problem
Pride and chest-puffing, the instinct that says "my way, always," are the enemy of a crew that can run without a boss standing over it. A crew works as a unit when everyone admits his own shortcomings and openly credits what somebody else does better. That's what lets the crew organize around who's actually best at what, instead of around who's highest up the tree.
A pile of individual egos can't do that. It needs a referee, and the referee is you, which means you're on site every day settling who does what. The ego isn't just a bad attitude. It's a bottleneck with your name on it.
The ego isn't just a bad attitude. It's a bottleneck with your name on it.
The antidote isn't a rule. A crew where everyone admits shortcomings only happens if the leader models it first. Your own humility, admitting out loud when you're wrong, when you're the one who left the ground crew hanging, is what gives the crew permission to be humble too. I wrote about setting the bar by leading from the front. This is the same move, aimed at the ego instead of the pace.
Moving on early is often the right call
Moving the aerial side to the next job early is often the efficient call. Setting up climbing gear or a bucket truck takes time, and that's time the rest of the crew would spend standing around.
The crew leader I mentioned wasn't wrong to leave. He was wrong about when. The flaw isn't moving on. It's the timing, and whether the aerial side helped get the crew caught up first.
He was wrong about when. The flaw isn't moving on. It's the timing, and whether the aerial side helped get the crew caught up first.
The timing rule
Move when the ground crew is down to its last couple of tasks. Raking. Cleaning up stump chips. By the time you're set up on the second job and ready to make a mess, the crew is pulling in behind you, catching up, and starts removing material as it comes down. Nobody standing around at the first job, nobody buried at the second.
Leave too early and you get the opposite. The crew finishes the first job only to find a tangled mess of brush already waiting at the second, and they start that job already behind. You didn't save any time. You moved it onto the people least able to absorb it.
The crew finishes the first job only to find a tangled mess of brush already waiting at the second, and they start that job already behind.
Leave too late and three guys stand there watching one guy set up a bucket truck.
The rule puts the decision on the ground, where the crew can see it. A climber who's done making a mess looks at the ground crew, sees they're down to the rake, and rolls. The crew comes first in the decision, and the crew knows it.
Coach the timing, not the attitude
When you coach this, coach the timing. Telling a climber he has an ego gets you an argument. Telling him the ground crew is still mid-pile and the next job can wait until the rakes come out gets you a climber who looks at the ground before he looks at the truck. Repeat it on enough jobs and he starts looking without being told. The judgment lives in him now, not in you.
Put yourself under the same rule. If you climb, you get caught up with your crew before you head to the next job, in front of them, every time. That's the humility that gives the crew permission to run itself. It's the leader showing that his time in the air doesn't outrank their time on the ground.
Freedom first, growth second
A crew that moves on its own timing is a crew that doesn't need you on site to referee who does what. The climber watches the ground. The ground crew knows the mess at the next job won't be waiting for them. That's freedom first: the crew organizes itself around the job instead of around rank, and a crew that organizes itself is a crew you can leave.
Growth comes second, and it's real. Jobs that flow into each other are more work done with the same crew and the same trucks, without you adding an hour. It's just not the reason to do it. It's what happens after.
Find the rest of your bottlenecks
Crew ego is one place the business leans on you. The Bottleneck Scorecard finds the rest in five minutes: seven questions, a score, and the one thing to fix first. No email required to see your result.